Case Digest: Consulta vs People GR 179462 12 Feb 2009
Art. 286: Grave Coercion | Criminal Law Facts: Pedro C. Consulta was found guilty of Robbery with Intimidation of Persons. On June 7, 1999, Nelia Silvestre and her companions were riding a tricycle in Makati City when they were blocked by the appellant and his brother. The appellant threatened and insulted Nelia, and then forcefully took her gold necklace before leaving. Nelia and her companions reported the incident to the police and sought medical examination. The appellant denied the charges and claimed that they were fabricated. He mentioned a history of disputes between his family and Nelia's family regarding rental payments. He also stated that Nelia had filed cases against him in the past, which were either dismissed or resulted in his acquittal. The appellant further claimed that Nelia would track his whereabouts and cause trouble despite his efforts to avoid her. The defense presented witnesses who ...